Costco’s Most Popular Fall Treat Is Back—and Bound To Fly off the Shelves

No one gets a jump start on the coming season like Costco. It’s not unusual to spot spooky Halloween decorations or frosted Christmas trees in their aisles so early in the year, they almost blend into the background.

However, there’s one limited-time treat whose arrival always catches our attention. It’s so highly anticipated by customers that it signals a change in the season faster than Punxsutawney Phil seeing his shadow.

This year, that world-class dessert has made its grand entrance at Costco earlier than usual, telling us it’s officially time to shelf the swim trunks and start prepping our Thanksgiving menus.

Costco’s Pumpkin Pie Is Officially Back for Fall

Attention Costco customers: Fall has officially arrived, and here’s the proof—the pumpkin pie is back in the bakery. For years, the beloved treat typically made its debut in early September. But after last year’s early August arrival, it seems the season for this bakery favorite is moving up for good—and we couldn’t be more excited about it.

Costco’s pumpkin pie has achieved an iconic status among its shoppers—many of whom call it “a staple in [their] fridge from September to November.” The classic recipe has remained unchanged for decades: a simple blend of pumpkin puree, eggs, sugar, and a mix of spices like cinnamon, nutmeg, and ginger, all baked in a tender, flaky crust. It’s balanced and not overly sweet—exactly what you would want from a pumpkin pie. 

And, best of all, you get nearly four pounds of it.

With its incredible 12-inch diameter, this pie ensures there’s plenty to go around a holiday table, plus enough leftovers to enjoy for days. But, what’s even more remarkable than its size is the pie’s price, which has famously held steady at just $5.99.

“My first thought was ‘there’s no way it’s still only $5.99,’” said one fan. “I’m pleasantly surprised.”

Costco sells millions of its made-in-house pies every year, and although sales usually peak around Thanksgiving, some fans can’t resist indulging long before November. Between its smooth, creamy texture and rich, warmly-spiced flavor, this is a dessert customers crave all through the autumn months. 

“I never liked pumpkin pie until I had Costco’s pumpkin pie!!! It’s soooo gooooood!!” commented one fan. “Never too early!!!” declared another. 

So if this treat is a fall tradition in your family, don’t wait to shop the bakery staple of the season.